I want to use this post to mark the passing of an extraordinary woman, Carol Bly, whose writing and teaching has had an impact on a great many people. As I remarked to a friend, she is one of those who, faced with the inhumane excesses of our age, put her foot down firmly, and declared “No more.” But she also knew that resistance and refusal is not enough. In everything she wrote she strove for illumination and understanding so that she could perfect her resistance to what she called “The Bully Who Rules the World” and change him.
I met Carol when, at the instigation of Linda McCarriston we were on a panel together at the Associated Writing Programs conference in Albany years ago, and I had the pleasure, the challenging pleasure, of continuing to correspond with her in the years since. She was the first to say “No more” to those funny emails quipping about Bush’s lack of intelligence, all those smug jokes about his being a buffoon. She pointed out that intellectuals always respond to the rise of tyrants by sneering in ways that make us feel superior and further disempower us by widening the gulf betwen ourselves and those to whom the demagoguery is designed to appeal. I stopped forwarding that stuff right away. She was dead on.
As she was about a great many things, large and small. Read her stories and you will never again be suckered into any kind of nonsense about how art cannot be filled with moral fervor, passion, and commitment.
Here is the obituary from the Minneapolis Star Tribune. If you do not know this writer, you should start with her book of stories, My Lord Bag of Rice.
Carol Bly, Minnesota’s lioness of letters, dies
The author and teacher was known for her strong moral voice in short stories and essays.
By SARAH T. WILLIAMS, Star Tribune
Last update: December 22, 2007 – 4:41 PM
True to form, Carol Bly stood stalwart against the dying of the light, dictating letters and thank-yous to friends, readers, well-wishers and fellow writers even in her final days. The lioness of Minnesota letters died Friday of ovarian cancer, surrounded by family and caregivers at the Pillars Hospice Home in Oakdale. She was 77.
“One of the great heavy lifters is gone,” said fellow writer and friend Bill Holm, of Minneota, Minn. “She never backed down from tackling large issues and large ideas in the culture.”
Bly, of St. Paul, had a milelong curriculum vitae that reflected a lifetime of writing, teaching, mentoring, editing and pamphleteering — even designing personalized crossword puzzles.
She was formidable — a tall, three-masted ship of a woman who could, in person or on the page, slice cleanly through pettiness, cruelty, shoddiness, dissembling or wrongdoing. Anyone engaging her in a casual “hello” could expect to be conscripted into action.
She was equally funny, Holm said, recalling a dinner party at which Bly assured a picky eater that the “ram’s milk” he was drinking from her farm was 100 percent organic. It took a while for the joke to sink in, Holm said.
Bly was born in 1930 in Duluth, Minn., to Russell and Mildred McLean. It was a childhood shadowed by war (all three of Bly’s brothers were in uniform during World War II) and her mother’s suffering (Mildred McLean died of tuberculosis when Carol was 12). She married Robert Bly in 1955, and the two joined forces against the Vietnam War, Watergate, nuclear testing and other issues in their own writings and a series of magazines they published together: The Fifties, The Sixties and The Seventies.
Their farmhouse in Madison, Minn., was an international hub for writers, poets and translators of every kind. Holm was a frequent visitor, as were James Wright, Donald Hall, Lewis Hyde, Louis Simpson, Tomas Tranströmer, Fred and Freya Manfred and many others.
It was not a place where one murmured politely about the weather, Holm said. “There was real talk at that table. People asked questions. There were playful arguments, witty ripostes — and needling. Carol loved to needle the guests about their political opinions, to chase them a little bit.”
She was a first-class hostess, Holm said, with an “infinitely expandable” dinner table. “There was always another chair and another — slightly chipped — plate.”
And she was a first-rate mother to her four children: Mary, Bridget, Noah and Micah. “What a great gift it would have been for any of us to have had her as a mother,” Holm said. “She was a genius at it — devising games for them, reading to them and keeping their minds, spirits and senses of humor alive.” Parental directives, he said, were delivered with a kind of British cheer: “‘Now, duckies,’ she’d say, ‘don’t you go using each others’ tooth brushes.’ Or ‘Now, duckies, we’re going to have a play after dinner.'”
Though they divorced in 1980 after 25 years of marriage, Robert and Carol remained civil toward one another and would brook no bad-mouthing of the other from outsiders.
“She was a light, a fire, for all those people wandering around on the prairie,” said Robert Bly, of Minneapolis. “She was an excellent mother. And a terrific friend of writers and of writing.”
Stories with backbone
After her divorce, Carol Bly moved to St. Paul, and ramped up her teaching and writing career.
Of her father, she once wrote: He was “more moral than social climber.” The same could be said of the daughter. In her writing, Bly stood her ground against “professional killing,” genocide, the bombing of whole cities, “rabbity” obedience to authority and individual and corporate bullying.
She believed that writers and readers had a duty beyond entertaining and being entertained, and explored this idea fully in “Changing the Bully Who Rules the World.” In the ambitious, 550-page book, selected essays, stories and poems — by Will Weaver, Charles Baxter, Denise Levertov and Jim Harrison, among others — serve as take-off points for discussions about moral and ethical stage development.
In her fiction, the often brave and sometimes despicable characters are drawn from the hardscrabble towns and farmhouses of rural Minnesota and the meaner streets of St. Paul. Among them are a nursing-home resident who defiantly heads into a blinding snow, a mortician whose father has trained him never to emote, an abused wife who refuses her dying husband his morphine, and a skinflinty rooming-house landlady who perceives the smallest gift to be a bribe.
Author and writing instructor Tobias Wolff, of Palo Alto, Calif., called her short stories “indelible, exemplary” and said he often uses them in the classroom at Stanford University. “They have a tremendous moral rigor … even a moral ferocity,” he said. “They push back against the world, against the unwitting complicities, the casual injustices that we’re all involved in — things that are done in our name far away. She is very demanding that we be alert to that kind of subversive quality of modern life.”
There’s a reason why her first collection of stories is called “Backbone,” said Emilie Buchwald, Bly’s longtime publisher at Milkweed. “That is exactly what all of her writing has: backbone.”
In 2004, Carol started Bly & Loveland Press with social worker Cynthia Loveland. The two produced pamphlets that took on violent TV programs, “do-nothing” clergy members, the “workshopping” of manuscripts (peer reviews in which students’ work is exposed to “drawing-room irony”) and conservative Republicans who “find themselves afraid.” The press also sold Bly’s personalized crossword puzzles — “ungeometric” with “genial clues.”
Loveland tended to Bly in her final days as she strove to finish a novel and keep up her correspondence. “Shelter Half” will be published in June by Holy Cow! press of Duluth. “I think it’s a masterwork,” publisher Jim Perlman said. “Her ability to draw characters and the rural landscape is just at the genius level as far as I’m concerned.”
Bly is survived by daughters Mary Bly (Alessandro Vettori) and Bridget Bly (Benjamin Bly), both of Summit, N.J.; sons Noah Bly (Karen) and Micah Bly (Chiemi), both of St. Paul; brothers John W. McLean of Tucson, Ariz., and Malcolm McLean of St. Paul; eight grandchildren, and numerous nieces and nephews. A memorial service is planned for early 2008.
Sarah T. Williams is the Star Tribune Books editor.